No. Artificial intelligence (AI) is creating opportunities for skilled equity long/short (ELS) managers to identify companies whose earnings prospects have been misjudged by markets. Capturing these opportunities requires navigating crowded trades and sharp reversals that can hurt both longs and shorts. Repeated setbacks since mid-year warrant closer scrutiny of whether managers are delivering the stock-selection alpha, diversification, and risk profile investors expect.
Following strong performance in recent years, ELS hedge funds have faced several bouts of equity market turbulence, renewing concerns about crowded AI-related positions. In July, falling AI infrastructure stocks and rebounding software names hurt both sides of some portfolios, with Situational Awareness a high-profile example of how concentrated, leveraged thematic bets can amplify losses and culminate in forced selling. In October, renewed weakness in AI-related stocks, particularly semiconductors, weighed on ELS performance amid de-risking across funds. Prime brokerage reporting documented episodes of long selling and short covering that reduced gross exposure.
Longs and shorts can offset market beta while reinforcing the same underlying bet. A portfolio with low net exposure may still depend heavily on technology stocks, momentum, or a common investment theme. Losses or rising volatility can prompt managers to reduce gross exposure voluntarily, while internal risk limits or tighter financing requirements can compel reductions. When investors reduce crowded positions simultaneously, they can amplify price moves and increase trading costs.
The case for ELS continues to rest on managers’ ability to generate stock-selection alpha after fees and expenses while delivering the intended portfolio risk profile. Simply reducing sensitivity to broad equity market movements is not enough; investors can achieve that more cheaply by combining passive equities with cash. Investors should look for demonstrated stock-selection skill and understand the role of the short book, whether as a source of alpha, a tool for managing risk, or both. Returns that are less closely tied to equity markets can support diversification, but they do not eliminate stock-specific volatility or drawdown risk.
As investors reassess AI’s potential to disrupt businesses and generate profits, skilled ELS managers can find opportunities for differentiated stock selection. AI disruption could produce increasingly divergent earnings prospects across technology businesses and the industries they serve. Where shared expectations drive companies’ stocks together, managers may find opportunities to distinguish between businesses with materially different prospects. More capable models may strengthen some companies’ competitive advantages while undermining others. The opportunity extends beyond infrastructure suppliers to businesses using AI to improve productivity, lower costs, or enhance their products. Productivity gains may lift margins or be competed away through lower prices. Managers need to assess who retains the economic benefits and where consensus expectations misjudge the resulting earnings, creating opportunities for alpha on both the long and short sides of the portfolio.
Still, a better opportunity set does not guarantee better returns. Narrative-driven buying can deepen mispricing and produce painful short-side losses. A company vulnerable to disruption can still rally sharply, while a fundamentally attractive business can fall as investors unwind crowded positions. Managers can correctly assess a business’s prospects yet fail to withstand adverse price moves long enough for a thesis to play out if position sizing, leverage, and liquidity are not prudently managed.
The managers best positioned to capture these opportunities are not necessarily those with the lowest net exposure or the least concentrated portfolios. More revealing characteristics include proprietary research that identifies changes in earnings prospects before consensus and independently underwritten longs and shorts. Managers also need the discipline to hold through price volatility and the flexibility to change positions when the underlying investment case changes. Investors rarely have a complete, current view of these managers’ positions. Available exposure reporting, manager discussions, and return patterns can help identify common risks within and across allocations, although each provides an incomplete picture. Due diligence should examine how managers assess crowding, size positions relative to liquidity, and manage leverage and financing through drawdowns.
We believe the investment case for ELS remains strong as AI reshapes business prospects. Investors should prioritize managers with demonstrated skill, a willingness to reassess their investment theses, and risk controls suited to their approach. Repeated losses from similar exposures warrant particular scrutiny. Evaluation of their causes and magnitude can help investors assess whether a manager’s portfolio is behaving as expected or exposing them to risks they did not intend to take.
Sean Duffin, Senior Investment Director, Investment Strategy Research